Sample pilot scorecard
Sample: what changed in 30 real questions
This is a sample for Acme, a fictional company. The questions, answers and counts show what a pilot scorecard looks like, not a measured result. A real one is graded by your own team lead, on your own questions.
20 questions the company's own people could answer, 10 controls they could not. The same questions were answered before and after the pilot, then graded blind by Sam Oduya, support team lead without knowing which answer was which.
12 of 20 in scope moved from wrong, incomplete or handed over to right. 0 of 10 controls got worse. 3 are still wrong. Wrong and confident: 8 before, 1 after. Keeplore had no rule for 3.
Questions frozen 29 September 2026. Graded 27 October 2026 by Sam Oduya, support team lead.
Moved to right12of 20 in scope
Controls got worse0of 10 controls
Still wrong3in scope, after
Wrong and confident8→1before to after
Pass line“At least 10 of the 20 in-scope questions move to a complete answer, and no control gets worse.”
Every question, both answers, both grades
1A customer on an annual plan wants a refund in week six. What do I do?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
Annual plans are refundable within 30 days of purchase. I can process that refund for you now.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Past the 14-day window, annual plans get a prorated credit note for the months left rather than a refund.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA customer on an annual plan asks for a refund after the 14-day window
DoIssue a prorated credit note for the months left. No cash refund.
“if they're past the 14-day window we do a prorated credit for the months left, as a credit note”Maya Chen, Billing lead
2Acme disputed an invoice and I'm about to close the ticket. Anything special?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
No. Close the ticket once the dispute is resolved and the credit will follow.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
For Acme, issue the credit before closing the dispute ticket, or their AP system rejects it.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenAn Acme invoice dispute is being closed
DoIssue the credit first, then close the dispute ticket.
“for Acme you issue the credit before closing the ticket”Maya Chen, Billing lead
3Who needs to approve a €7,000 credit?
In scope BeforeCorrect but incomplete
Credits are issued by the billing team.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Anything over €5,000 goes to Maya Chen for approval before it's issued.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA credit is for more than €5,000
DoSend it to Maya Chen for approval before issuing it.
“Anything over 5,000 euros comes to me for approval”Maya Chen, Billing lead
4Does Acme have any special terms I should know about?
In scope BeforeCorrectly declined
I don't have information about special terms for individual accounts.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Yes. The terms are in a note on the Acme account in Salesforce; read it before replying.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenYou need the special terms agreed with Acme
DoRead the note on the Acme account in Salesforce before replying.
“There's a note on the Acme account in Salesforce but nobody reads it”Maya Chen, Billing lead
5A SEPA direct debit failed. Do I email the customer?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
Yes, let the customer know their payment failed and ask them to update their details.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Not yet. The debit is retried once after three working days; email only if the retry fails too.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA SEPA direct debit fails
DoRetry once after three working days. Only email the customer if the retry fails too.
“we retry once after three working days and only then email them”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
6A customer opened a chargeback. What's the first step?
In scope BeforeWrong
Reply to the customer to understand why they disputed the charge.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Send the case to Dana Vos in finance the same day with the invoice number, before replying to the customer.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA customer opens a chargeback
DoSend the case to Dana Vos in finance the same day, with the invoice number. Don't reply to the customer first.
“chargebacks go to Dana the same day, with the invoice number, before anyone writes back”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
7Can I extend a trial by a week?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
Trial extensions need to be requested through your account manager.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Yes, support can extend a trial by up to 14 days without asking anyone.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA trial customer asks for more time
DoExtend the trial by up to 14 days without asking anyone. Longer than that goes to the account manager.
“up to two weeks we just extend it, longer than that the account manager decides”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
8Someone asked us to delete all their data. Can support do that?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
I can help you delete your account data. Please confirm and I'll proceed.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
No. Forward the request to privacy@ within one working day; support never deletes data itself.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA customer asks for their data to be deleted
DoForward the request to privacy@ within one working day. Support never deletes anything itself.
“deletion requests go to privacy within a working day, we never delete anything from support”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
9An enterprise customer wants to add a clause to their contract. Can I say yes?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
Contract terms can be discussed. Let me know what change you'd like.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
No. Contract changes go to their account manager; support never agrees them.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenAn enterprise customer wants to change their contract
DoHand over to their account manager. Support never agrees contract changes.
“contract changes are the account manager's, support never says yes to those”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
10A customer was charged twice. Do I need approval to refund the second payment?
In scope BeforeCorrect but incomplete
Refunds are reviewed case by case by the billing team.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
No. A duplicate payment is refunded within five days without approval.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA customer was charged twice for the same invoice
DoRefund the second payment within five days without asking for approval.
“a double payment we just refund, within five days, no approval needed”Maya Chen, Billing lead
11A reseller customer wants a copy of their invoice. Can I send it?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
Of course, I'll send the invoice to the email on the account.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
No. Invoices for reseller customers go to the reseller, never to the end customer.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA customer who came through a reseller asks for an invoice
DoSend invoices to the reseller, never to the end customer.
“reseller customers never get an invoice from us, it goes to the reseller”Maya Chen, Billing lead
12What discount does a certified partner get?
In scope BeforeCorrectly declined
Partner discounts vary. Please contact the partnerships team.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Certified partners get 20%. Check the partner list before confirming.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenA partner asks about their discount
DoCertified partners get 20%. Check the partner list before confirming.
“certified partners get twenty percent, and I always check the partner list first”Maya Chen, Billing lead
13What's the refund window on a monthly plan?
In scope BeforeCorrect and complete
Monthly plans can be refunded within 14 days of the charge.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Monthly plans can be refunded within 14 days of the charge.
Your agent14How do I change the billing email on an account?
In scope BeforeCorrect and complete
In Settings, Billing, change the billing contact and save.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
In Settings, Billing, change the billing contact and save.
Your agent15Which payment methods do we accept?
In scope BeforeCorrect and complete
Card, SEPA direct debit and bank transfer for annual plans.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Card, SEPA direct debit and bank transfer for annual plans.
Your agent16Where does a customer download their invoices?
In scope BeforeCorrect and complete
Under Settings, Billing, Invoices.
Your agentAfterCorrect and complete
Under Settings, Billing, Invoices.
Your agent17A customer in Switzerland asks whether VAT applies to their invoice. What do I say?
In scope BeforeWrong and confident
VAT is charged on all invoices.
Your agentAfterWrong and confident
VAT is charged on all invoices.
Your agentKeeplore had no rule for this after the pilot.
18A customer wants to downgrade mid-term and get the difference back. Do we do that?
In scope BeforeWrong
Yes, we refund the difference on downgrades.
Your agentAfterWrong
Downgrades take effect at the next renewal.
Your agentKeeplore had no rule for this after the pilot.
19The customer paid in dollars but the invoice is in euros. Who fixes that?
In scope BeforeWrong
Please contact your bank.
Your agentAfterWrong
Please contact your bank.
Your agentKeeplore had no rule for this after the pilot.
20Can a customer pay a yearly plan in quarterly instalments?
In scope BeforeCorrectly declined
I'm not able to answer that.
Your agentAfterCorrect but incomplete
Possibly. Ask the account manager.
Your agentRules Keeplore used afterWhenAn enterprise customer wants to change their contract
DoHand over to their account manager. Support never agrees contract changes.
“contract changes are the account manager's, support never says yes to those”Jonas Berg, Support team lead
21When will the mobile app support offline mode?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
I don't have information about the roadmap.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
I don't have information about the roadmap.
Your agent22What's the API rate limit on the Team plan?
Control BeforeCorrect but incomplete
Rate limits depend on your plan. Check the API docs.
Your agentAfterCorrect but incomplete
Rate limits depend on your plan. Check the API docs.
Your agent23How do I set up SSO with Okta?
Control BeforeCorrect but incomplete
SSO setup is covered in the admin guide.
Your agentAfterCorrect but incomplete
SSO setup is covered in the admin guide.
Your agent24Which data centre hosts EU accounts?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
I can't share infrastructure details.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
I can't share infrastructure details.
Your agent25Do you integrate with NetSuite?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
I'm not sure. Please ask sales.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
I'm not sure. Please ask sales.
Your agent26Are you SOC 2 certified?
Control BeforeCorrect but incomplete
Security details are on the trust page.
Your agentAfterCorrect but incomplete
Security details are on the trust page.
Your agent27What uptime does the SLA guarantee?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
I don't have the SLA figures.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
I don't have the SLA figures.
Your agent28What would 500 seats cost?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
Please contact sales for a quote.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
Please contact sales for a quote.
Your agent29How do I export the audit log?
Control BeforeCorrect but incomplete
Audit logs are available to admins.
Your agentAfterCorrect but incomplete
Audit logs are available to admins.
Your agent30Is there a Zapier integration?
Control BeforeCorrectly declined
I'm not able to confirm that.
Your agentAfterCorrectly declined
I'm not able to confirm that.
Your agent
Keeplore had no rule for these
3 in scopeEach one is a person at the company still to be interviewed.
- A customer in Switzerland asks whether VAT applies to their invoice. What do I say?
- A customer wants to downgrade mid-term and get the difference back. Do we do that?
- The customer paid in dollars but the invoice is in euros. Who fixes that?